Do You Understand The Reverse Mortgage Closing Costs?

Posted on May 24, 2010 by Beth Paterson, CRMP

Signing Reverse Mortgage Application As with a conventional mortgage, there are costs associated with a reverse mortgage. While perceived as high, once understood you’ll see the reverse mortgage costs are comparable to a conventional loan. Most people don’t understand the fees, what they cover or why they have to be paid with a conventional loan either, they just accept them as part of doing a loan.

One difference is that with the HUD insured reverse mortgage, the Home Equity Conversion Mortgage (HECM), HUD regulates the fees and does not allow marked up or “junk fees,” borrowers only pay the actual costs.

To get clear, let’s understand what the Minnesota fees are and what they cover.

Fee	Explanation	Cost/Charge
Origination Fee	Covers the lender’s time and costs associated with originating the loan including: loan officer’s and staff’s salary, administrative costs, business overhead (computers, office space, utilities, health insurance, office supplies, marketing, processing, underwriting, etc.) (Note processing and underwriting fees are generally additional fees on conventional loans but have to be included in the origination fee on FHA reverse mortgages loans.)	HUD sets guidelines for the origination fee: Maximum of 2% of the first $200,000 of the home value or lending limit, 1% on the balance thereafter with a cap of $6,000 or a minimum of $2,500.
FHA Mortgage Insurance Premium	A required charge from FHA because they are insuring the loan. Keeps the interest rate lower, allows more to be borrowed, guarantee funds are available, and covers risk so borrower or heirs are not personally liable.	2% of the property value or mortgage lending limit, whichever is less.
Appraisal	Fee for FHA licensed appraiser to determine the market value of the property. Includes a management fee for an independent company to order the appraisal.	$450 – $500
Repair Administration Fee	All loans with repairs are charged an administration fee for overseeing that the repairs are completed, ordering inspection, processing payments, etc.	1.5% of the repair bid
Credit Report Fee	This is to check if there are any liens or judgements against the property or person that would need to be paid or other contradictory information.	$18 – $20
Flood Certification Fee	For verifying whether flood insurance is required or not.	$15 – $20
Courier Fee	To send pay offs to a current lender if there are any.	Approximately $30 each
Counseling by Third-party HUD approved counselor	A fee may be charged to the borrower for counseling services as long as it does not create a hardship. The counselors must make a determination about the borrowers ability to pay which may include factors such as income and debt obligations – HUD recommends a written procedure for this. Counselors must inform borrowers of the fee structure in advance of services and cannot be turned away, nor the counseling certificate be withheld based on failure to pay. The Counseling fee may become part of the costs at closing.	Up to $125 allowed by HUD
Document Preparation Fee	Charge for preparing the loan documents for closing. A specialized company prepares the loan package.	$100-$125
Escrow, Settlement or Closing Fee	Charged by the title company for handling the title work and closing of the loan.- – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – -Sometimes there is an additional signing/notary fee or an additional fee for going to a borrower’s home.	Generally $250 – $350- – – – – – – – – – – – – – – $125-$200 signing/ notary fee
Abstract or Title Search	This charge is for searching the county records.	$150-$185
Title Examination	This is for the examiner to review the title and put the commitment together.	$135-$150
Title Insurance	Title company’s insurance on the property guaranteeing clear ownership and protect lender if there is a defect in the title. Different than owner’s title insurance policy.	Based on property value.
Recording Fees	Fees for recording documents with the county such as mortgage, deeds, county taxes, bankruptcy, name change due to divorce or loss of spouse	$46 each + a $5 conservation fee
County Tax	Mortgage Registration Tax required in Minnesota and collected by the county.	Based on Principal Limit
Survey/Plat Drawing; Name & Assessment Search	Fee for obtaining and reviewing the plat drawing; Fee for searching names and assessments on title	$60; $30; $30 = $120 combined (higher for some counties)
Fees Paid by Lender to Broker such as Yield Spread Premium; Service Release Premium; Lender Paid Broker Compensation	Brokers/originating lenders are paid in two ways, one by you (the origination fee) the other by the lenders. Lenders pay brokers/originating lenders compensation for submitting loans to their company. This compensation also covers the broker’s/originating lender’s time and costs associated with their running their business.It does need to be disclosed on the Good Faith Estimate. Note that federally chartered banks do not have to disclose this information to borrowers even though the same compensation is paid.	This is NOT A BORROWER EXPENSE!To disclose this to you, on the GFE it will be shown as a fee then credited back so it is not actually charged to you.

As the RESPA (Real Estate Settlement and Procedures Act) changes effective January 1, 2010 a Good Faith Estimate (GFE) can ONLY be provided with an actual application. It is no longer allowed for the informational or quote package to include a GFE.

Information (in addition to the name, birthday, property information, current loan details,) that will trigger the application include the Social Security Number, Monthly Income, assets, debts, any other pertinent information. This information should NOT be provided until lender is chosen and ready to proceed with an application. Once lenders have this information they may start processing the loan.

Note that the fees, other than the Appraisal and possibly the counseling fee, are wrapped into the loan so there are no other out of pocket costs.

Being clear and having an understanding of the reverse mortgage costs helps you make better decisions and takes the fear away from the reverse mortgage.

This material may be re-posted provided it is re-posted in its entirety without modifications and includes the contact information, copyright information and the following link: http://wp.me/p4EUZQ-kg

Blog posts’ information is current as of date post published, program is subject to change in in the future. Contact us for current information, 651-762-9648.

This site or the information provided is not from, or approved by, HUD, FHA, or any US Government or Agency.

A Letter to Minnesota Governor Tim Pawlenty Regarding Reverse Mortgages

Posted on May 17, 2010 by Beth Paterson, CRMP

From the time I first heard about the proposed reverse mortgage legislation in 2009, SF489, I have been writing to and in contact with MN Governor Pawlenty’s office. This year even prior to having details of the bill I started contacting Governor Pawlenty’s office, sending emails regarding the suspected legislation. After Friday evening May 14, 2010 when I finally found the details of the bill SF2430 I again sent Governor Pawlenty a message requesting a veto this time outlining with the details of the issues of the bill. Following is the latest letter I sent to him requesting a veto.

Dear Governor Pawlenty,

After having time to review the reverse mortgage amendment to SF2430/HF2699 I want to provide the reasons why this reverse mortgage legislation should be vetoed.

Besides the facts I have pointed out previously:

This bill has not been transparent – the amendment was just added on the afternoon of May 14, 2010 with no prior knowledge of the details to those of us in the reverse mortgage industry.
This reverse mortgage legislation is controversial. Any reverse mortgage legislation should not happen without a full hearing.
While it appears they pulled the language of suitability, this bill still contains some of the same language as the 2009 SF489/HF528 which was vetoed last year which would mean increased costs to reveres mortgage borrowers and/or cause some lenders to refrain from offering reverse mortgages in Minnesota.

The main issues include:

1. Why should a lender receive a civil penalty an dhave to pay $1,000 for something a counselor does or doesn’t do? Who and how is this going to be overseen?

The language of this is subjective setting up an opportunity for litigation and lenders may decide not to lend in the state if there is a risk of civil penalty for something they have no control over.

Implementing state laws that are different than the HUD requirements will make it more difficult for prospective borrowers to receive counseling.
- Some of the counseling opportunities currently available to our Minnesota borrowers will no longer be an option as some of the counseling agencies may decide that with different regulations they will not provide counseling in the state.
Having the state oversee counseling different than the HUD requirements is likely to be costly for the state in seeing that these regulations are followed by counselors in the state as well as across the country.

2. Adding the language for Lender default and forfeiture may mean lenders will choose not to loan with this requirement and HUD may choose not to insure the loans with these requirements.

3. Seven-day cooling off period; right of rescission will mean the loans will be more expensive for seniors and without the opportunity to waive the provision under certain circumstances such as foreclosure may mean that seniors could lose their home because the reverse mortgage could not be done timely.

It appears they changed the 10-day rescission period language to a seven-day cooling off period but it would have the same negative consequences as the 10-day rescission period.
Language is vague and subjective, i.e. “written commitment to make the reverse mortgage loan. “ What does “written commitment” mean? This makes it more likely for litigation.

4. This law would be additional costs to the state. While the bill may not be showing as a having a budget expenditure, there would be additional costs to the state in overseeing that state laws are followed versus the difference from the federal regulations. If the loan becomes more expensive to seniors and/or lenders choose not to loan in the state more seniors are likely to lose their homes without the reverse mortgage option. Consequently the foreclosures would increase and more housing would be needed for seniors and much of this would be born as state expense.

5. All lenders do not have to abide by the state rules. Federal chartered banks do not have to abide by the state rules because they are federal chartered yet brokers and non-federal chartered banks and lenders would have to follow any state laws. This would be a monopolistic-like advantage for the FDIC banks over other lenders. This obviously does not foster fair competition between all lenders and small business.

6. Seniors can apply for and if they qualify can receive a conventional or home equity loan to refinance without all the regulations that are done with a reverse mortgage. Sometimes they may feel it is easier and less invasive to do so. Unfortunately many who have taken a conventional or home equity loan run into problems making the required monthly payments then inquire about a reverse mortgage. With the lower home values many times these seniors do not qualify for the reverse mortgage and then often face foreclosure and lose their homes. Or they may just use credit cards to finance their retirement expenses then run into problems when they can’t make the payments. There aren’t additional requirements for seniors to qualify for credit cards. And there aren’t additional requirements for seniors to take out a car loan. So why have such tight regulations on reverse mortgages when seniors can make other choices that could be more detrimental to them.

7. Implementing this legislation is insulting to our seniors who have worked hard all of their lives – they are not children, they have lots of experience and knowledge – some that we could and should learn from – so why are we treating them like children? They have the right to be educated on their options then decide what is right for their situation, not have legislators, counselors, or lenders make decisions for them.

Keep in mind that: A reverse mortgage is a mortgage just like any other loan but has special terms for seniors 62 and older. And besides the special terms to benefit them to qualify and improve their life the reverse mortgage borrowers are already highly protected (see attached article)! I would like to educate those making legislative decisions on the facts and terms of reverse mortgages then determine what legislation needs to be implemented for proprietary reverse mortgages.

Again, I ask that you veto the reverse mortgage legislation SF2430/HF2699 to protect Minnesota Seniors and the reverse mortgage businesses.

Thank you,

Beth Paterson
Executive Vice President
Prestige Mortgage LLC
Reverse Mortgages SIDAC
Security, Independence, Dignity and Control
The Experts Excelling In Service
Phone: 651-762-9648
Toll Free: 1-877-590-9648
Fax: 651-653-0878
Be sure to visit our website and
Blog for reverse mortgage facts and details:
www.RMSIDAC.com and
http://BethsReverseMortgageBlog.wordpress.com
Follow on http://Twitter.com/RMSIDAC

While Governor Pawlenty recognizes the issues as he stated in his 2009 veto letter, the unfortunate fact is that this legislation was not a stand alone bill but is attached to a foreclosure bill and without the line-item-veto authority may be signed into law. If this is the case it will be very unfortunate for Minnesota seniors as well as the reverse mortgage industry.

Blog posts’ information is current as of date post published, program is subject to change in in the future. Contact us for current information, 651-762-9648.

This site or the information provided is not from, or approved by, HUD, FHA, or any US Government or Agency.

Beware Of Reverse Mortgage Misstatements – The Fact Is Reverse Mortgage Lenders Do NOT Own The Home!

Posted on March 21, 2010 by Beth Paterson, CRMP

There are many myths and misconceptions of reverse mortgages! Probably the most flagrant is the misconception that reverse mortgage lenders own the home. I get very frustrated when I constantly see or hear the statements: “You lose ownership of your home.” “The lender will own the home.” and “Good for the lender, bad for the borrower.”

The fact is a reverse mortgage is a mortgage just like any other mortgage where the borrower is using the equity of their home to meet their needs and desires now. As with a conventional mortgage, a reverse mortgage is a method of using the home as collateral to borrow money and a lien is placed against the property. The title remains in the borrowers’ name. The borrower is still responsible for taxes, insurance, maintaining the home, and abiding by the terms of the loan.

The difference between a conventional mortgage and the reverse mortgage:

Terms	Conventional Mortgage	Reverse Mortgage
Retain Title/Own Home	Yes	Yes
Use Home For Collateral	Yes	Yes
Lien Placed Against Property	Yes	Yes
Income Requirements	Yes*	No
Credit Score Requirements	Yes*	No
Monthly Payments Requirements	Yes*	No
Repayment term	15 years, 30 years, etc.*	When home is no longer primary residence or 150^th birthday of borrower
Closing Costs	Origination fee, third party fees, possibly FHA Mortgage Insurance Premium	Origination fee, third party fees, FHA Mortgage Insurance Premium
Amount To Be Repaid	Loan Balance	Loan Balance
Non-recourse, there are is no personal liability to the borrower(s) or their heirs as long as they are not retaining ownership	Not an option – full loan balance is due and would be paid from the estate if not from the sale from the home	Yes, the estate would not have to come up with the difference if the loan balance is higher than what the home can be sold for.

*Terms and interest rate is determined by income, assets, credit score, ability to make payments and points.

The reverse mortgage needs to be in first lien position which means any current liens or mortgages must be paid off from the proceeds of the new loan. When refinancing with conventional home equity loans current liens or mortgages must also be paid off. In either situation there needs to be enough equity from the home to pay off any current mortgage.

Sometimes one can take a second mortgage with a conventional mortgage. With a reverse mortgage HUD does not allow a second mortgage. If the reverse mortgage funds are not enough to pay off the current mortgage, the borrower may choose to pay down the difference with their own funds or gifted funds. The intention of HUD is that borrowers are not incurring debt in order to do a reverse mortgage.

When Linda passed away and the loan became due and payable her heirs sold the home, they chose the real estate agent and made the decision of what the listing price would be as well as decided on the acceptable sale price. In this situation the home was sold for more than the loan balance so the remaining equity went to the heirs. The title of the home had remained in Linda’s name with the reverse mortgage, she was able to have funds to meet her needs and the heirs were able to receive the remaining equity.

Dennis took out his reverse mortgage in 2002. When he passed away this year the reverse mortgage loan balance was higher than what the house could be sold for. In his situation the FHA Mortgage Insurance Premium covered the difference so his heirs did not have to come up with the difference. Dennis was able retain ownership of his home and to use the equity during his lifetime for his needs and he did not leave a debt to his children.

With either a conventional mortgage or a reverse mortgage borrowers own the home, the title remains in their name and the mortgage is a method of using the home as collateral to borrower money. For seniors there are many advantages to doing a reverse mortgage instead of a conventional mortgage.

This material may be re-posted provided it is re-posted in its entirety without modifications and includes the contact information, copyright information and the following link: http://wp.me/p4EUZQ-hE

Blog posts’ information is current as of date post published, program is subject to change in in the future. Contact us for current information, 651-762-9648.

This site or the information provided is not from, or approved by, HUD, FHA, or any US Government or Agency.

Which Is Best… A Fixed Rate or Adjustable Rate Reverse Mortgage?

Posted on March 14, 2010 by Beth Paterson, CRMP

Adjustable rates mortgages have gotten a bad rap but with the reverse mortgage they should be considered. While considered the most desirable, a fixed rate is not necessarily the best option. Let’s discuss the advantages and disadvantages of each.

First you need to know how the loan amount is determined. With the reverse mortgage the Principal Limit or maximum loan amount at the time of origination is determined by the home appraised value or FHA’s Maximum Claim Amount ($625,500 through 2010), the age of the borrower, and the Expected Interest Rate. The Expected Interest Rate is only used to determine the loan amount it is not necessarily the same as the interest rate on the loan.

Currently the Expected Interest Rate on the Fixed Rate is lower than on the Adjustable Rate therefore the initial Principal Limit on the Fixed Rate option is higher than the Adjustable Rate option. But this still does not make the Fixed Rate always the best option.

The Adjustable Interest Rate has the option of receiving funds as monthly payments, a line of credit, lump sum or a combination of these. All the funds need to be drawn as a lump sum to receive the best interest rate with the Fixed Rate option. While HUD requires that lenders offer the monthly and line of credit options with Fixed Rate, the interest rate would be so high that these options are never even discussed with the Fixed Rate.

Jerri needed some extra funds and was doing a reverse mortgage to meet these needs. Her situation was she didn’t have a current mortgage and she was already receiving Medical Assistance (Medicaid in MN).

When we compared the Fixed Rate to the Adjustable Rate based on her home value and age, Jeri would receive more funds with the Fixed Rate. However if she would choose the Fixed Rate option she would have to draw all the funds up front. Drawing all the funds up front would mean that unless she spent them in the month they were received she would lose her Medical Assistance.

While not receiving as much available upfront, by choosing the Adjustable Rate she could take out what she needs immediately in the lump sum and leave the balance in a line of credit and draw it when she needs it. Being the Line of Credit grows at a half percent more than the interest rate of the loan, she could have more funds available to her in the future. (Loans originated after the Fall of 2010 the growth rate is 1.25% more than the interest rate of the loan, i.e. if the interest rate is 2.5% the growth rate would be 3.75%.)

Jeri chose the Adjustable Rate so she would not lose her Medical Assistance yet have the funds she needs to meet her needs.

Tom wanted to improve his cash flow and found that making the mortgage payments on his current mortgage was a challenge. With the reverse mortgage Tom’s cash flow would improve because his current mortgage would be paid off eliminating his $1,200 monthly payments. And with the reverse mortgage monthly payments are not required. This means he has the $1,200 that he was paying in mortgage payments to no use as he needs.

In his situation the Fixed Rate would pay off his current loan and provide Tom about $8,000 more in a lump sum. Reverse Mortgage Borrower decides on option best for his situation

When we compared the Adjustable Rate option to the Fixed Rate, there was about $10,000 less available with the Adjustable Rate option. And in order to pay off his current loan Tom would need to bring about $2,000 to the closing. (The reverse mortgage lender needs to be in first lien position so all current loans need to be paid off with the reverse mortgage.)

In comparison Tom would receive $8,000 additional funds at closing with the Fixed Rate versus having to bring $2,000 to the closing with the Adjustable Rate.

Being Tom is not on Medical Assistance and he also wanted some funds upfront to pay off some credit card debt the Fixed Rate would not negatively impact him.

When Tom met with the reverse mortgage counselor he was told that if he could come up with the $2,000 the adjustable rate would be able to be done and they would have more funds when the reverse mortgage was being paid off. This is not necessarily the case.

On the surface when looking at the Estimated Amortization Schedule it does appear that the remaining equity would be higher. However it is speculative to guess what the interest rate is going to be on the Adjustable Rate option in the future. And one needs to keep in mind that the Amortization Schedule is an estimate based on the current interest rate.

Currently the initial rate on the Adjustable Interest Rate is lower than the Fixed Interest Rate so it may look more favorable. Unfortunately we don’t know if the Adjustable Rate will remain as low as it currently is, in other words it’s not guaranteed to remain the same. So if the interest rate jumps high at some point in time in the future, the remaining equity could be the same or less than what could be available from the Fixed Rate.

The Home Equity Conversion Mortgage (HECM), currently the only reverse mortgage option available in Minnesota, is insured by HUD. HUD guarantees the funds are available to the borrower, helps keep the interest rate lower, allows for the funds in the Line of Credit to grow and protects the borrower as a non-recourse loan. This means there is no personal liability to the borrower or the estate as long as they are not retaining ownership.

In Jeri’s situation by doing the Adjustable Rate while she may not receive as much up front, she will have the funds guaranteed and the growth rate on the line of credit. Additionally even if the reverse mortgage interest rate does go up, when the loan is due and payable if the loan balance is higher than the home can be sold for, she or her estate will not need to come up with the difference (the non-recourse protection).

In Tom’s situation, while when the loan is due and payable he may or may not have more equity if he did the Adjustable Rate, with the Fixed Rate he is receiving $8,000 at closing rather than having to come up with $2,000. By using the $8,000 wisely, i.e. paying off credit card debt with very high interest rates and then saving the remainder in a saving account that may earn a little interest, he has the reverse mortgage interest rate guaranteed.

As was the case when the Fixed Rate was first introduced, at some point in the future the Expected Interest Rate on the Adjustable may be lower than the Fixed Rate and provide more funds to the borrower. Not having a crystal ball we need to review each interest rate option and look at each situation as an individual circumstance without judging whether the Fixed Rate or the Adjustable Rate is better. One shoe doesn’t fit everyone and one reverse mortgage interest rate option does not fit everyone. The Adjustable Interest Rate may fit better for some circumstances and the Fixed Interest Rate better for others.

Blog posts’ information is current as of date post published, program is subject to change in in the future. Contact us for current information, 651-762-9648.

This site or the information provided is not from, or approved by, HUD, FHA, or any US Government or Agency.

You Need To Know Reverse Mortgage Borrowers Are Highly Protected!

Posted on March 7, 2010 by Beth Paterson, CRMP

Legislators, media, some senior advocate groups, and even the general public miss the point that reverse mortgage borrowers are already highly protected. With more protections than with any other loan or financial decision seniors make they still feel more protections are needed. Currently the only reverse mortgage is the Home Equity Conversion Mortgage (HECM) which is insured by HUD. HUD has guidelines and requirements to protect seniors. Even when there were proprietary (private) reverse mortgage products, they followed HUD’s guidelines. While there are protections, seniors still have the right to make their own decisions, for better or worse. Let’s discuss these protections.

Third-party counseling is required on all reverse mortgages. Counseling is absolutely mandated with no exceptions and is provided by HUD trained and approved counselors. During the counseling sessions the counselors are required to follow a protocol approved by HUD. Evolving over time, HUD’s counseling guidelines and regulations now require distance between the counselors and lenders. Lenders are required to provide borrowers with a list of 5 local and 5 national counselors without steering borrowers to any specific counselor. Additionally, counselors are restricted from steering to lenders.
- The counselor’s role is to educate about reverse mortgages, explain the allowable fees, and terms of the loan so potential borrowers have an understanding of the reverse mortgage. They also provide other potential options. They counselors are not to make a decision for the borrower on whether they should or should not do the reverse mortgage.

Cross-selling is prohibited. Mortgagee Letter 2008-24 (HUD’s guidelines and requirements) states that a “HECM mortgage originator or any other party that participates in the origination of a FHA insured HECM mortgage shall not participate in, or be associated with, or employ any party that participates in or is associated with, any other financial or insurance activity.” Additionally if a lender or bank has financial departments they must demonstrate to the Secretary of HUD that they have and maintain “firewalls and other safeguards designed to ensure that (i) individuals participating in the origination of a HECM mortgage have no involvement with, or incentive to provide the mortgagor with, any other financial or insurance product; and (ii) the mortgagor shall not be required, directly or indirectly, as a condition of obtaining a mortgage under this section, to purchase any other financial or insurance product.”
- Lenders require mortgage brokers sign forms that they do not sell insurance and do not cross-sell.
- All lenders application packages have disclosures stating that annuities and/or other financial products are not required to be purchased with reverse mortgage funds.

HUD regulates the fees. HUD outlines what lenders and third-parties may charge stating they must be customary and reasonable costs necessary to close the mortgage. Mark-ups are not allowed. You may find HUD guidelines at their website (http://www.hud.gov/offices/hsg/sfh/ref/sfhp2-15.cfm) and in Mortgagee Letters 2008-34; 2006-07; 2006-04; 2004-18; 2000-10.

The Good Faith Estimate (GFE) must disclose all fees. RESPA (Real Estate Settlement and Protections Act) requires all fees be disclosed at the time of application, restricts what fees can be changed and for the fees that can be changed borrowers must receive new disclosures.

The Total Annual Loan Costs (TALC) must be disclosed. Providing a comparison of the percent of the costs to the amount received through the loan, this document discloses that the longer one keeps the loan the less expensive it is.

Sample Closing Documents must be provided at the time of application. HUD requires that borrowers must receive the sample closing documents as well as a booklet regarding home equity loans. This gives borrowers time to review the documents they will be signing at closing. They may also have family, trusted friends or their attorney review the documents during the processing.

Disclosures must be provided to borrowers at application. There are a variety of disclosures including:
- Non-borrowing spouse disclosures outlining the risks if a spouse will not be on the loan.
- Taxes and Insurances are the responsibility of the borrower(s).
- Annuities and/or other insurance and financial products are not required with a reverse mortgage.
  - If annuities are being purchased the costs of the annuity are to be included on the TALC.

Three-day Right of Recession. As with any refinance, there is a three-day right of recession giving the borrower(s) time to review and decide whether or not to proceed.

HUD insures and guarantees the funds. As a HUD insured loan the funds are guaranteed to be available to the borrower as long as the borrower(s) abide by the terms of the loan.

Non-recourse loan. Unlike any other loan, the reverse mortgage is a non-recourse loan which means there is no personal liability to the borrower or the estate as long as the borrower or their estate is not retaining ownership when the loan is due and payable.

There are guidelines for marketing practices. HUD, The Federal Trade Commission and industry associations review and have cracked down on misleading advertisements.

State licensing and the SAFE Act. Many states require mortgage brokers take test and receive licensing in order to originate loans including reverse mortgages. (Note: FDIC insured banks are exempt from these requirements.) The Housing and Economic Recovery Act of 2008 (HERA) enhances consumer protections including encouraging states to establish minimum standards for licensing and registration of mortgage loan originators. The SAFE Act will establish and maintain a national mortgage licensing system and registry for the residential mortgage industry.

Protected MN Reverse Mortgage Borrowers

When doing other types of mortgages, loans or financial decisions seniors do not have all of these same protections. For example they do not have to go through counseling, have the same disclosures requirements, have regulated fees, are not guaranteed or have the non-recourse clause and often do not require the testing and licensing. Think about these situations that don’t have these same requirements or disclosures:

A reverse mortgage compares to a regular home equity loan in the fact that regardless of age the mortgages are used to finance lifestyle using the home equity. With a forward/conventional loan the funds are taken as a lump sum and can be used however one wishes.

If a senior is selling they have costs associated with sale and receive funds in a lump sum. No one is controlling how they use the remaining equity from the sale of the home. And they have to determine where they are going to live. If they are renting (i.e. regular apartment, independent living, or assisted living) the money may only last for a short period of time and they may still not have funds for future needs.

If the senior (or anyone) does a forward/conventional loan the funds are received in a lump sum. They can do whatever they want with this equity. And they have to make payments which can become difficult for them if “life happens.”

If they win the lottery they have money in a lump sum which can be spent however they wish.

With credit cards seniors (or anyone) are not restricted on how they are used. They can charge for whatever they want. And they then have created debt that has to be paid back on a monthly basis.

When you hear that seniors need to be “protected from the reverse mortgage” remember all these protections and know that seniors doing a reverse mortgage have more protections than any other loan or financial decision they make. As with any decision, especially financial or legal, one should be educated and understand the service or product. And while these protections are in place, the seniors still have a right to decide for themselves on whether the reverse mortgage is right for their situation.

Blog posts’ information is current as of date post published, program is subject to change in in the future. Contact us for current information, 651-762-9648.

This site or the information provided is not from, or approved by, HUD, FHA, or any US Government or Agency.

Irrational Statements Show Ignorance of Reverse Mortgages

Posted on January 25, 2010 by Beth Paterson, CRMP

Have you made or heard these statements? “Stay away from reverse mortgages!” “I wouldn’t recommend a reverse mortgage.” “It’s the worst thing you could do.” “Reverse mortgages are a scam.” “Don’t do it! Too many things can go wrong.” “Reverse mortgages only benefit the banks.” “The bank owns the home.” “You can outlive the mortgage.” These statements get my ire up because it shows people making these statements don’t know what they are talking about when it comes to reverse mortgages.

Let me give you the facts: A reverse mortgage is a mortgage just like any loan against the home but it has special terms for seniors 62 and older.

There are no income or credit score requirements to qualify.
No monthly payments required.
There is no limitation on how the funds can be used.
Funds can be received in monthly payments structured as needed, line of credit (with a growth rate), lump sum, or a combination of these.
Social Security and Medicare are not affected because it is a loan.
Medicaid can still be received with the reverse mortgage.
Borrowers can stay in the home as long as it is their primary residence or in the case of a couple as long as one borrower is still in the home as their primary residence.
The loan is non-recourse which means there is no personal liability to the borrower or their heirs if they are not retaining ownership. So they don’t have to come up with the difference if the loan balance is higher than what the home is be sold for as long as they are not retaining ownership.
At the time of sale if the home is sold for more than the loan balance, the borrower(s) or their heirs receive the difference.

Just like any mortgage, borrowers still have the title and are responsible for property taxes and insurance, association dues (if applicable), maintaining the property and abiding by the terms of the loan.

FHA offers and insures the majority of reverse mortgages known as the Home Equity Conversion Mortgage, or HECM, making it the most highly regulated mortgage available. Lenders are regulated by RESPA (Real Estate Settlement Procedures Act) and HUD (Housing and Urban Development). Funds are guaranteed by HUD. Application and Closing documents include many disclosures, in fact at the time of Application it is required that sample closing documents be provided to the borrowers. Additionally, all borrowers are required to go through third-party counseling by HUD approved counselors.

Fees are regulated and only HUD allowed fees are permitted with no mark-ups. Even though many times they are considered expensive or high the compare to conventional loans, in fact the difference comes down to FHA Mortgage Insurance Premium. You can see a comparison of the costs in my article, “Reverse Mortgage Costs – High or Mythical?”

In the last few years HUD and RESPA have implemented more regulations and protections. And recently HUD has been charging those who have not followed these regulations and even pulled their licensing.

Happy MN Reverse Mortgage Borrower

The reverse mortgage has been a life saver for many. According to an AARP report 93% of the borrowers are satisfied. Based on a survey of our borrowers our company has 100% satisfaction. I just talked with one borrower last week who told me the reverse mortgage has made a huge positive difference in her and the one her sister had made a big difference in her life also. (Her sister has now passed away.) One day we received a call from a man who said, “I want a reverse mortgage because since Jim got his, he’s a new man.” Some of my other Blog posts share other stories on how the reverse mortgage has made a difference in the lives of seniors: “Finance Retirement With A Reverse Mortgage,” “Know A Senior Who Wants Security, Independence, Dignity, and Control? A Reverse Mortgage May Be The Answer!” “Reverse Mortgages Finance Home Care,” and “Reverse Mortgages Answers Prayers.”

I’ve posted some Blog articles addressing the media’s attacks on reverse mortgages, “The Media Needs The Reverse Mortgage Facts,” “But Wait, There’s More… Reverse Mortgage Facts The Media Needs To Know,” and “It Is NOT Reverse Mortgage Fraud When…” It’s obvious the public needs these facts too when they make the statements that are in the opening paragraph.

When people make such irrational statements they don’t know what they are talking about. The reverse mortgage is not right for everyone but everyone has the right to get the details and facts so their decision can be based on the truth, not on opinion. As asked in my Blog, “When You Don’t Know What You Don’t Know About Reverse Mortgages,” would you go to a plumber for health problems? And to expand on that, would you go to a general practitioner if you have heart problems? No, you would go to the specialist. So before making or believing such irrational statements, contact a specialist and get the facts. Our website, www.RMSIDAC.com is full of information and facts and if you are in Minnesota we’d love to provide the facts for you via phone or in person.

Blog posts’ information is current as of date post published, program is subject to change in in the future. Contact us for current information, 651-762-9648.

This site or the information provided is not from, or approved by, HUD, FHA, or any US Government or Agency.

A Reverse Mortgage Or A Conventional Mortgage For Senior Homeowners? That Is The Question.

Posted on January 17, 2010 by Beth Paterson, CRMP

The call comes in: “I took a loan out 3 years ago and now I want a reverse mortgage because I can’t make the payments.” I respond, “Great, the reverse mortgage eliminates mortgage payments and allows borrowers to stay in their home.” I define that a reverse mortgage is a mortgage like any other loan but with special terms for seniors 62 and older and borrowers still have the title and are responsible for property taxes and insurance, association dues (if applicable), maintaining the property and abiding by the terms of the loan. Then I also review some other details of the reverse mortgage including that:

There are no income or credit score requirements to qualify.
No monthly payments required.
There is no limitation on how the funds can be used.
Funds can be received in monthly payments structured as needed, line of credit (with a growth rate), lump sum, or a combination of these.
Social Security and Medicare are not affected because it is a loan.
Medicaid can still be received with the reverse mortgage.
The loan is non-recourse which means there is no personal liability to the borrower or their heirs if they are not retaining ownership.
If the home is sold for more than the loan balance, the borrowers or their estate keep the difference.

Then after further discussion and review of their situation, I state, “Let me get some information so I can see how much reverse mortgage proceeds there are in your situation.”

The reverse mortgage needs to be in first lien position which means any current liens need to be paid off with the reverse mortgage. There needs to be enough funds from the reverse mortgage to do this. Often when a mortgage was done a few years ago, when I run the numbers I often find there aren’t enough proceeds to pay off their current mortgage. Sometimes they are only short a few hundred dollars and they can come up with the funds needed to do the reverse mortgage (sometimes it’s only a matter of a monthly payment). Other times they are short thousands. For one couple who called a couple of weeks ago they were short over $40,000 to pay off their current mortgage. Once I run the calculation with these scenarios I then have the difficult call back to tell this senior that the reverse mortgage is not an option.

I often hear of 70 and 80 year olds who are taking out a 30 year conventional mortgage and then they have to work in order to make the mortgage payments. What happens when they can’t work and can’t make their mortgage payment?

I wish they would get the facts on reverse mortgages and get over their fear and do the reverse mortgage instead of a conventional mortgage in the first place. Instead of doing the conventional loan, if the reverse mortgage would have been done originally the senior would be in a different situation now – a much better one.

Lower home values and higher loan balances contribute to the issue. While the reverse mortgage rate is historically lower than conventional mortgages and the reverse mortgage has many benefits over conventional loans, there was a fear that made the senior take out a conventional mortgage instead of a reverse mortgage. Then “life happens” and we get the call and we often have to deliver the bad news, not enough reverse mortgages funds to pay off the currant mortgage.

Closing costs are comparable (See my Blog, “Reverse Mortgage Costs – High or Mythical’), interest rates historically lower, so in the big picture the reverse mortgage costs less. No monthly payments and options on how the funds can be received, the guarantee of funds and non-recourse features all make a reverse mortgage a better choice for seniors.

Even if one can qualify for a conventional loan today, when “life happens” (health, medical issues, can’t or don’t want to work any more, home repairs or modifications needed) and the monthly payment can’t be made, the seniors get into the balancing act of, “Do I make my mortgage payment or pay my other expenses.” and if they can’t or don’t make the payments they’ll be at risk of foreclosure. With the reverse mortgage this risk goes away because no monthly payments are required so they don’t have to worry about deciding between paying the mortgage or their other expenses.

Let’s look at one senior couple. Four years ago they took out a conventional loan for $25,000 to meet their immediate needs. Last year because they needed more funds they looked at a reverse mortgage. Based on their home value of $120,000 and their age they would qualify for $75,000 in reverse mortgage funds, closing costs of $9,000 and a lower interest than their current conventional loan or than what they would qualify for on a new conventional loan. (Remember to qualify for a conventional loan income, credit, assets and risks are taken into consideration to determine interest rate. The reverse mortgage interest rate is not affected by income, credit, or assets.)

Yes, the closing costs on the $25,000 conventional loan were lower than the reverse mortgage because the conventional bases the fees on the amount received, $25,000 in this case and the reverse mortgage bases the fees on the full home value – this is because over time they can be access the full home value or even more than the home value. In their situation the initial loan closing costs were $3,000 for the conventional loan.

With the reverse mortgage they would have had a lower interest rate, no monthly payment requirements and funds in a line of credit that would grow so more would be available for future needs. One can’t get these benefits with any other loan.

They decide against the reverse mortgage and to do a conventional loan for another $25,000 and pay closing costs of another $3,000.

Now let’s look their situation in another two years:

They initially accessed $25,000 with closing costs of $3,000
The 2^nd loan they accessed for another $25,000 with closing costs of another $3,000 totally $50,000 in funds received and $6,000 in closing costs.
Looking at their financial history, in another 2 years more than likely they will be contacting their bank for another loan. So at this point their situation would be (if they can even qualify) another $25,000 and another $3,000 in closing costs totally accessing $75,000 and a total of $9,000 in closing costs. This doesn’t include the interest rate expense that would be higher than on a reverse mortgage.

They would have been smarter if the reverse mortgage would have been done initially or at least at this point in time. Over time would have been able to access more than $75,000 including the growth rate, closing costs would have been the same and interest expense would have been less. In addition they would not have had to make payments, improving their cash flow through the years, the funds would be guaranteed for them, and the reverse mortgage is non-recourse so in the end they only pay what the home could be sold for without having to come up with the difference, or they get to keep any remaining equity if the home is sold for more than the loan balance. (On a conventional loan the borrower or the estate could be responsible for the difference if the loan balance is higher than what the home can be sold for.)

And a few years from now they may not qualify for a conventional loan so they would have paid the $6,000 in closing costs to receive $50,000 and have made payments through the years. Then when “life happens” and they can’t afford those payments, they could be facing foreclosure, and maybe not qualifying for a reverse mortgage. And if they do qualify for the reverse mortgage, they will then have to pay the closing costs adding the closing expense on top of what they have already paid. All in all, the reverse mortgage would have been less expense in the long run. View “Is Waiting To Do A Reverse Mortgage The Best Decision” for a comparison of funds now or in the future. It’s important to note that their banker thought that the reverse mortgage through us was a much better option for this couple.

Satisfied MN Reverse Mortgage Client

Marlene who initially did a conventional mortgage and then turned to us to do a reverse mortgage said when she did the conventional loan she didn’t understand the reverse mortgage and so was afraid to do it. At the reverse mortgage closing she said she wished she had done the reverse mortgage in the first place. She’s just glad that we were able to help with the reverse mortgage when we did.

In conclusion, when one is in their senior years the reverse mortgage is generally a better choice than a conventional mortgage, even if they do qualify for a conventional loan. If one does the reverse mortgage instead of a conventional loan their retirement years will be so much smoother, less stressful – they’ll have peace of mind along with security, independence, dignity, and control. And when at a future date they do decide to do a reverse mortgage we won’t have to deliver the bad news that there aren’t enough funds to pay off a current mortgage. They should have done the reverse mortgage in the first place.

Blog posts’ information is current as of date post published, program is subject to change in in the future. Contact us for current information, 651-762-9648.

This site or the information provided is not from, or approved by, HUD, FHA, or any US Government or Agency.

Changes With The Good Faith Estimate Leave Reverse Mortgage Borrowers Confused And At Risk

Posted on January 9, 2010 by Beth Paterson, CRMP

Reviewing Reverse Mortgage Fees

As we welcome in the new year we are also looking at many changes with reverse mortgages. The first of which is the New RESPA (Real Estate Settlement and Procedures Act) requirements. These include a new Good Faith Estimate (GFE) and HUD-1 (closing Settlement Statement). (Note, these RESPA changes apply to conventional loans also – so if you are looking are refinancing or purchasing you’ll want to be familiar with them too.) The intent is to make it easier for borrowers to compare fees between service providers, application and final HUD-1 Settlement Statement fees, and disclosure of yield spread premiums or lender paid fees.

With the new regulations a GFE will ONLY be provided with an actual application. It is no longer allowed for the informational or quote package to include a GFE. The borrowers are at risk because they may just want to receive estimates on the fees when they request a GFE, and not knowing the new regulations they will be signing an application and the broker/lender may start processing the loan even before they’ve made a final decision – especially the unethical originators and lenders. Besides the info needed for information purposes such as name, address, birth dates, home value/estimated home value, amount of balance of current loans, information that will trigger the application include the Social Security Number, monthly income and assets and other pertinent personal information. This information should NOT be provided until lender is chosen and ready to proceed with an application.

Included are now three fee categories on the GFE: those that cannot change, those that have a 10% tolerance, and those that can change without restrictions. There are areas of allowance for “Changed circumstances” which will include:

Fees that may change due to a difference in the appraised value include, i.e. origination fee, FHA Mortgage Insurance Premium, Title Insurance, MN Registration Tax, inspections, surveys, certifications, etc.
Required services not known prior to the application, such as but not limited to roof, foundation, engineering inspections or certifications, and surveys.
Recording fees for unknown liens, mortgages, loans, judgements, title changes such as deeds, trusts, death certificates, Power of Attorney, and release fees, etc.
Required services by providers chosen by borrower rather than the lender, such as title services and fees, title insurance, and notary fees
Other circumstances particular to the borrower of transaction, including the need for flood insurance or environmental problems
Acts of God, War, disaster or other emergency
Changing from one product to another.
Home Owners Insurance

A new GFE will need to be provided to the borrower within 3 days for these changes to be permitted at closing. It is the broker/lender’s responsibility to disclose and document the disclosure of the new GFE to the borrower(s). If not disclosed properly, the broker/lender will have to pay the difference, it cannot be charged to the borrower(s).

At the time of inquiry and for information purposes only, we, Prestige Mortgage/Reverse Mortgages SIDAC, will, as we have always done, be providing an explanation of closing costs.

While we have always provided accurate GFE’s (usually within only $100 difference between application and actual fees at closing) you can now expect all lenders to be providing the GFE fees to be the same as at closing.

Unfortunately in the process of trying to make sure all fees are disclosed to borrowers the new 3 page GFE (formerly 1-page) is more complicated and will be more confusing for borrowers. We will do our best to help borrowers understand the fees, changes, and forms.

Review a comparison of Minnesota Reverse Mortgage costs to conventional loan fees in the post, “Reverse Mortgage Costs – High or Mythical?”

Blog posts’ information is current as of date post published, program is subject to change in in the future. Contact us for current information, 651-762-9648.

This site or the information provided is not from, or approved by, HUD, FHA, or any US Government or Agency.

One Bad Apple Spoils The Bushel of Reverse Mortgages

Posted on October 26, 2009 by Beth Paterson, CRMP

Reverse Mortgage Apples Every industry has their bad apples and reverse mortgages are no exception. However the few and far between “bad apples” in the reverse mortgage industry are not representative of the industry or the product as politicians, media and some reporters are stating. Headlines such as “Beware of Reverse Mortgages” is a disservice to seniors because it scares away the seniors who could benefit from a reverse mortgage. So even the reporters and politicians are bad apples spoiling the bushel of reverse mortgages.

There is little evidence of subprime lending and fraud with reverse mortgages. The National Consumer Law Center Report recently released which claims reverse mortgages are the next subprime mortgage is not based on statistical evidence. As Peter Bell, President of the National Reverse Mortgage Lender’s Association has pointed out, the cases sited in this report are over 3 years old and some have been dismissed in the legal system.

Some of the instances mentioned in this report are not abuses by lenders but by those who took advantage of seniors who had the reverse mortgage. My Blog article, “It is NOT Reverse Mortgage Fraud When…” outlines some claims of reverse mortgage fraud that aren’t really reverse mortgage fraud.

Let’s look at the bad apples of fraud in the reverse mortgage industry:

One bad apple was where a scheme was set up to flip homes using a reverse mortgage.
Another bad apple was an investor who sells the property using a quit claim deed then the buyer applies for a reverse mortgage using an inflated appraisal and a fake mortgage company. The senior then refinances using a reverse mortgage paying off all debts including the fake mortgage providing the investor funds – some of these seniors were homeless prior to the scheme and didn’t understand the terms of the loan or the need to pay taxes and insurance on the property. Protections have been implemented to stop these types of schemes.
An originator who proceeded with the loan closing knowing the borrower had passed away was another bad apple.
HUD has charged another bad apple for violating HUD’s regulations and is in the process of proceedings to have that company’s FHA license pulled and the people involved will be put on HUD’s sanction list and not be allowed to work in the industry. (This lender does both conventional and reverse mortgages – the violations were based on conventional loans, not reverse mortgages s0 this was not really reverse mortgage fraud but it likely could have been.)

Out of all the reverse mortgage lenders and reverse mortgages these are the only instances I found to be real fraud and this is not an issue with the product itself but with a person or persons. If there are more, I couldn’t find them in my search of reverse mortgage fraud through the many sites and articles found at the FBI, Federal Trade Commission, HUD, National Reverse Mortgage Lender Association, and other industry reports. Obviously with only these instances, reverse mortgage schemes and fraud are not increasing or set to be the next subprime focus.

Yes, there is always a risk of potential increase of scams and fraud as there is a risk of increase of scams with anything including increase of theft from a store, identity theft, medical or insurance practices or products, on and on. And while everyone doing a reverse mortgage, a conventional mortgage or any financial transaction should know the facts and beware of scams, three or four instances does not mean the product should be avoided. Would you stop shopping because it involves using cash or a bank card just because there is a risk of increase of theft or identity theft? No, you just take precautions. Do you stop driving your car because there is a risk of increase of car theft. No, of course not, you just take precautions.

HUD has many protections in place making the reverse mortgage the safest loan available to seniors. These protections include required third-party counseling, now with a new protocol (see my Blog article “New Protocol for Reverse Mortgage Counseling”), regulating fees, prohibiting cross-selling, implementing a wait period for home purchases (a result of a scam) as well as review of marketing practices and disclosure of fees.

Meg Burns, Director, FHA Single Family Program Development U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD) has stated, “the program has the potential to benefit seniors with a wide variety of financial needs and, as such, should be thoughtfully considered by all seniors making financial planning decisions.” She has stated that widespread abuse is unsubstantiated and shares the reverse mortgage industry’s concern about decisions based on lack of knowledge, as outlined in her statement, “I have grave concerns about the overzealous attention by legislators to the reverse-mortgage sector. Federal regulators are going to pay attention, but they don’t know the product. We have yet another party entering this world who wants to layer on additional consumer protection, but they don’t understand the product well enough-[and yet] we have auditors nipping at our heels.”

Instead of highlighting how many seniors have benefitted from the hundreds of thousands reverse mortgages that have been done and how originators have bent over backwards to help seniors save their home from foreclosure, eliminate mortgage payments, have cash to repair or modify their home or have funds for medical expenses or home health care, or funds for their retirement during the economic downturn the media and politicians focus on the rare instance of fraud.

Consider a few of the many comments we have received on how the reverse mortgage made a difference for seniors:

“Thank you! I now have my bills paid, money in the bank, and I can take a vacation this summer.”
“It helps me keep up with bills I cannot cover with my limited income. It also allowed me to remodel my home to improve its value and be more comfortable. I greatly appreciate it.”
“The Reverse Mortgage helps out a great deal and solves many problems.”
“It has relieved us of a great deal of stress and makes grocery shopping a lot easier too.”
“The only way we could comfortably stay in our home of 42 years”
“A reverse mortgage means I’ll have a place to live even in case of serious illness.”

Options should be considered however their homework has not been done when reporters, politicians, and even “senior advocacy” groups state:

“The reverse mortgage should be a last resort.” A last resort to what? As one of my borrowers stated, “When retired it is the last resort.”
“Get a home-equity line.” First, most seniors don’t qualify for a conventional loan and if they could, they would have to make payments (often what they are trying to eliminate or avoid). And even if they can afford the payments today, what happens when “life happens” and they juggle between making mortgage payments, paying their utilities or paying medical bills and putting food on the table.

Besides, the reverse mortgage IS a home equity loan. It is a home equity loan with special terms for seniors including no income or credit score qualifications, no monthly payments and is a non-recourse loan insured by FHA with a lower interest than they can qualify for with a conventional “forward” loan. The loan is not due and payable until the home is no longer the primary residence or on their 150^th birthday. It also offers more flexibility on how they can receive their funds including monthly payments, line of credit, lump sum or a combination of these.

“Sell and move.” Most seniors want to stay in their home where they have raised their children, are familiar with the neighbors and neighborhood and have a lot of emotional ties. Additionally moving and selling can cost more than a reverse mortgage. Read my Blog, “I Want To Stay In My Home – Don’t Tell Me To Sell!” which compares the costs.

Another common misstatement and myth is “reverse mortgages have high fees.” Actually the costs of the reverse mortgage are comparable to a conventional FHA loan. When comparing costs side by side to a conventional loan the difference is the up-front FHA Mortgage Insurance Premium. The benefits of FHA insuring the loan include guaranteed funds, a lower interest and the loan being non-recourse. For a better understanding of costs and a comparison read “Reverse Mortgage Closing Costs – High or Mythical?”

To make sure you aren’t working with a predatory lender, check references, check to ensure they are a HUD approved lender, know they specialize in reverse mortgages, have experience, knowledge, and are willing to meet with you to review the details, before the application, during the application and at closing. You should review “Don’t Let Fear Keep You From A Reverse Mortgage But Know What To Look For In A Lender” to know the questions to ask when talking with an originator.

Our company is proud to receive comments such as “I am completely satisfied with all aspects of my reverse mortgage. From start to finish, it was handled very professionally. I never had a feeling that my questions and input were not of importance (thank you – I had many questions!!) Beth, you assured me that the procedure was on time and going smoothly, and that was a wonderful feeling! Thank you for being the kind of super advisor that makes you so special”

So don’t let the bad apple spoil the bushel of reverse mortgages for you. Get the facts, know what to look for in a lender, and explore the option to see if it might benefit you as it has benefitted hundreds of thousands of senior homeowners.

To get the details and facts straight, the media should read a couple of my other Blog articles: “The Media Needs Their Reverse Mortgage Facts!” “But Wait, There’s More… Reverse Mortgage Facts the Media Needs To Know” and “When You Don’t Know What You Don’t Know About Reverse Mortgages.”

Blog posts’ information is current as of date post published, program is subject to change in in the future. Contact us for current information, 651-762-9648.

This site or the information provided is not from, or approved by, HUD, FHA, or any US Government or Agency.

New Protocol for Reverse Mortgage Counseling

Posted on October 19, 2009 by Beth Paterson, CRMP

Since its inception when HUD started insuring reverse mortgages 20 years ago, anyone considering a reverse mortgage must receive counseling from a 3^rd party HUD approved counselor. Now effective this October a new protocol has been put into affect. To remain on HUD’s Counseling Roster, counselors must have passed the National HECM (Home Equity Conversion Mortgage) Counseling Exam. Only counselors who are employees of HUD-approved housing counseling agencies can take the exam and then be eligible to counsel potential reverse mortgage borrowers. Additionally they must have completed at least one HECM related training course within the past two years and meet some background check requirements.

With the intention to keep lenders from influencing counselors, lenders are required to provide potential borrowers with a list of 10 counselors, 5 are to be local and the additional 5 are the national counseling agencies. Also according to HUD’s requirements lenders are prohibited to provide only one or two counselors and/or steering to a particular counselor.

The purpose of the third party counseling is to make sure potential borrowers are familiar with the terms of the loan, the costs, and advise them of other potential options. The advantages can be if the potential borrowers have not talked with a lender or a lender has not provided the details they are getting the basics of the reverse mortgage. If they have talked with a lender and the lender has done a good job explaining the reverse mortgage, the counselor will reiterate what the lender has explained. Counseling sessions should generally take about an hour and HUD allows counselors to charge up to $125 commensurate with the time of the counseling session.

Through the years we, the ethical lenders, have been amazed how counselors have not followed HUD’s requirements, steered to particular lenders, told borrowers they shouldn’t do the reverse mortgage, how they should take their reverse mortgage funds, charged the full allowable amount of $125 for only 15 minutes of counseling time, and a number of other violations of HUD’s regulations.

When we from Prestige Mortgage, LLC, Reverse Mortgages SIDAC, meet with our prospective borrowers we usually take an hour to two hours going through the details and the calculations, reviewing their situation and discussing options for their situation. After the counseling session when we ask our borrowers how the counseling session went, we consistently hear, “They covered just what you did.” This means our borrowers have received enough education to have a good understanding of the loan.

Besides the new protocol to be a counselor, there will be a new protocol for the counseling session. Prior to the counseling session HUD is requiring that prospective borrowers receive calculation pages comparing programs, the amortization schedules, the Total Annual Loan Cost (TALC) and a booklet titled, “Use Your Home to Stay at Home” published by the National Council on Aging.

From what we understand counselors will be doing a financial analysis. Additionally counselors will be asking 10 questions in which borrowers will need to answer at least 5 correctly in order for them to receive the counseling certificate. If they can’t answer the questions correctly then they will not receive the certificate and will need to wait a minimum of 7 days and then go through another “limited” counseling session to review the topics they didn’t understand. And if counselors feel the prospective borrowers don’t comprehend the basic reverse mortgage details, they can withhold the counseling certificate.

The intention is to help borrowers assess their situation and whether the reverse mortgage is right for their financial situation. While on the surface this sounds like a good idea, the concern is whether the counselor will be passing along their opinion and not letting the borrower really make their own decisions and withholding the counseling certificate if they choose based on their opinion. This has happened in the past with counselors telling borrowers they should cut back on getting their hair done, not using the proceeds for a trip, shutting off their cable TV, etc.. I believe the discussion should be held however, the final decision should still be the borrowers. And we have to consider what provides seniors their security, independence, dignity, control and choices of their life. Visit my Blog articles: “Who Are We To Judge How Reverse Mortgage Funds Should be Used?” and “Is Your Opinion of Reverse Mortgages Denying Seniors?”

I’m proud that we take so much time educating our borrowers and discussing their situation and options so they can make their decision based on the facts of the reverse mortgage. Also that they have the information and knowledge to be able to answer the questions they will be asked during the counseling session.

With the new protocol of the counselors, I believe (hope) the best counselors will remain and the counseling sessions will provide the education without the opinions of the counselors being shared. I also hope that the counselors will be following the required protocol knowing that if they don’t HUD is likely to pull their ability to counsel. Time will tell if the new protocol of the counselors and the counseling session will benefit borrowers or make it more cumbersome and/or discouraging for the borrowers.

The best I can do is continue to educate borrowers on the facts of reverse mortgages, discuss their situation and options and respect them to make the decision best for their own situation and have the information they need when they go through the counseling session.

Blog posts’ information is current as of date post published, program is subject to change in in the future. Contact us for current information, 651-762-9648.

This site or the information provided is not from, or approved by, HUD, FHA, or any US Government or Agency.

Minnesota Reverse Mortgages SIDAC

Minnesota Reverse Mortgage Information, Facts and News from the Experts Excelling in Service

Tag Archives: Reverse Mortgage Costs

Do You Understand The Reverse Mortgage Closing Costs?

A Letter to Minnesota Governor Tim Pawlenty Regarding Reverse Mortgages

Beware Of Reverse Mortgage Misstatements – The Fact Is Reverse Mortgage Lenders Do NOT Own The Home!

Which Is Best… A Fixed Rate or Adjustable Rate Reverse Mortgage?

You Need To Know Reverse Mortgage Borrowers Are Highly Protected!

Irrational Statements Show Ignorance of Reverse Mortgages

A Reverse Mortgage Or A Conventional Mortgage For Senior Homeowners? That Is The Question.

Changes With The Good Faith Estimate Leave Reverse Mortgage Borrowers Confused And At Risk

One Bad Apple Spoils The Bushel of Reverse Mortgages

New Protocol for Reverse Mortgage Counseling